What Are the Most Common Hiring Mistakes Companies Make?

The True Cost of Hiring a New Employee in the UK

The average cost of hiring a new employee in the UK is around £3,000, but this can be much higher if you use recruitment agencies in the UK, many of whom charge up to 35% of the employee’s salary. This means that for a salary of £50,000, you could be paying out more than £17,000 in recruitment costs, and that doesn’t include the hidden costs of lost time, interviews, training, or the onboarding process. With the cost of a bad hire being so significant, it’s crucial to avoid common hiring mistakes and make the right hiring decision the first time. Below are some of the most frequent recruitment mistakes employers make.

Rushing the Recruitment Process

When a business is in desperate need of a new hire, it’s easy to rush the recruitment process. With up to 86% of UK job seekers failing to attend interviews—often without notifying the employer—many companies struggle to get candidates through the door. This high interview no-show rate often increases pressure on hiring managers, leading to rushed decisions, poor candidate screening, and ultimately, costly hiring mistakes. Hiring too quickly can lead to selecting someone who isn’t the right fit or lacks the skills needed for the role, adding to the overall cost of replacing an employee.

Running an Inefficient Interview Process

An inefficient interview process is another major reason companies end up with the wrong candidate. A well-structured, effective interview process should include planned interview questions, consistency between interviewers, and trained hiring managers who know how to evaluate candidates objectively. Without a structured interview, employers risk asking irrelevant questions or failing to gather the information needed to make a confident hiring decision. Inefficient interviews increase the likelihood of bad hires, prolong the hiring cycle, and inflate overall UK recruitment costs.

Allowing Unconscious Bias to Influence Hiring

Unconscious bias in hiring is extremely common. Many people naturally gravitate toward candidates who are similar to themselves. When hiring managers recruit based on familiarity rather than qualifications, it leads to poor decision-making and a lack of diversity in the workplace. This reduces innovation, affects team dynamics, and often means the most qualified person is overlooked. Reducing unconscious bias is essential for fair recruitment, improving diversity and inclusion, and preventing expensive recruitment mistakes.

Failing to Provide a Proper Onboarding Process

Even after hiring the right candidate, a poor onboarding process can undo all the hard work. Effective onboarding should include introductions to colleagues, a guided tour of the workplace, clarity around duties and expectations, and access to tools and resources necessary for success. Unfortunately, many employers overlook the importance of employee onboarding, which leads to early resignations and drives up the overall cost of hiring and training new employees. When onboarding is done poorly, employee turnover is high, the cycle starts all over again—with additional time, money, and productivity lost.

At Inspired CVs, we provide tailored guidance and professional support for both employers and employees. Our services include expert HR and recruitment advice, as well as professionally written, customised CVs designed to highlight your strengths and improve hiring outcomes.

Whether you’re looking to enhance your recruitment process or strengthen your career prospects, our team is here to help. Contact us today, or place your order directly, to get personalised support from industry professionals.